If the waning weeks of 2011 hadn’t gotten away from me, I’d
have given Girls and Los Campesinos! the full B+ reviews they deserve, but my
reservations about both records (Girls made a theoretically admirable move towards
Big Rock that led them to the actually tedious land of flutes and seven-minute
run times, while the unsurprisingly clever Los Campesinos! album was
unsurprising in most other ways too) were serious enough that I decided to
include both in this final nod to the year just passed. Elsewhere, The Roots
affirm my uneasy feelings about concept albums, but still turn in their second
admirable record in as many years; Fallout Boy front man Patrick Stump uses his
Micheal Jackson impression to put across some disarmingly articulate songs
about pushing 30 in the lower reaches of the 99%; and Coldplay, a band I don't
hate on for sport, spends the better part of an hour in search of a memorable
tune.
Girls: Father, Son, Holy Ghost (“Honey Bunny,” “Alex,”
“Jamie Marie”)
Los Campesinos!: Hello Sadness (“By Your Hand,” “Songs About Your Girlfriend,” “Hello Sadness”)
Patrick Stump: Soul Punk (“Run Dry,” “Coast,” “Bad Side of25”)
The Roots: Undun (“Kool On,” “The OtherSide,” “I Remember”)
Ryan Adams: Ashes & Fire (“Dirty Rain,” “Lucky Now”)
Phonte: Charity Starts at Home (“Everything is Falling Down”)
The Black Keys: El Camino (“Little Black Submarines”)
Florence + the Machine: Ceremonials (“Shake It Out”)
AVOID
Coldplay: Mylo Xyloto
The Weeknd: Thursday
